P&P, Paid & Penalized

Public Medicare data, made visible.

Metro area

Saginaw, MI

2 of 2 hospitals take a cut in FY2027: 100% of the 2 measured on at least one condition. The average cut, counting all 2 hospitals, is 0.35%. Estimated total: $301Kestimate.

Saginaw, MI · FY2027Compared with all hospitals nationally

1Hospitals

2

2Penalized

100%

of 2 measured · +17 pts vs nation

3Average cut

0.35%

same as nation

4Cut 1% or more

0

0% of hospitals (nation 8%)

5At the 3% cap

0

6Estimated dollars

$301Kestimate

Hospitals on the map

Figure 1. 2 of the 2 hospitals here take a cut; the largest, 0.48%, is at Covenant Medical Center.
Beaumont Hospital Royal Oak, Royal Oak, MI: cut 0.03%Ascension Providence Hospital, Southfield and Novi, Southfield, MI: cut 0.11%Edward W Sparrow Hospital, Lansing, MI: no cutBeaumont Hospital, Troy, Troy, MI: cut 0.16%Trinity Health Oakland Hospital, Pontiac, MI: cut 0.30%McLaren Bay Region, Bay City, MI: cut 1.64%Hurley Medical Center, Flint, MI: cut 0.06%McLaren Flint, Flint, MI: cut 0.27%Beaumont Hospital - Farmington Hills, Farmington Hills, MI: cut 0.35%McLaren Greater Lansing, Lansing, MI: cut 0.06%McLaren Lapeer Region, Lapeer, MI: cut 0.84%Henry Ford Health Warren Hospital, Warren, MI: no cutAscension Genesys Hospital, Grand Blanc, MI: cut 0.10%Mymichigan Medical Center Midland, Midland, MI: cut 0.11%Ascension Providence Rochester Hospital, Rochester, MI: cut 0.44%Huron Valley-Sinai Hospital, Commerce Township, MI: cut 0.30%Henry Ford Health West Bloomfield Hospital, W Bloomfield, MI: cut 0.46%Mymichigan Medical Center Alma, Alma, MI: cut 0.21%Trinity Health Livingston Hospital, Howell, MI: cut 0.20%McLaren Central Michigan, Mount Pleasant, MI: cut 0.05%Mymichigan Medical Center West Branch, West Branch, MI: cut 0.06%Tawas St Joseph Hospital, Tawas City, MI: cut 0.30%Memorial Healthcare, Owosso, MI: cut 0.57%Mymichigan Medical Center Clare, Clare, MI: cut 0.17%McLaren Oakland, Pontiac, MI: cut 0.05%University of Michigan Health-Sparrow Carson, Carson City, MI: no cutSoutheast Michigan Surgical Hospital LLC, Warren, MI: no cutSurgeons Choice Medical Center, Southfield, MI: no cutMymichigan Medical Center Saginaw, Saginaw, MI: cut 0.22%Covenant Medical Center, Saginaw, MI: cut 0.48% Beaumont Hospital Royal Oak, Royal Oak, MI: cut 0.03%Ascension Providence Hospital, Southfield and Novi, Southfield, MI: cut 0.11%Edward W Sparrow Hospital, Lansing, MI: no cutBeaumont Hospital, Troy, Troy, MI: cut 0.16%Trinity Health Oakland Hospital, Pontiac, MI: cut 0.30%McLaren Bay Region, Bay City, MI: cut 1.64%Hurley Medical Center, Flint, MI: cut 0.06%McLaren Flint, Flint, MI: cut 0.27%Beaumont Hospital - Farmington Hills, Farmington Hills, MI: cut 0.35%McLaren Greater Lansing, Lansing, MI: cut 0.06%McLaren Lapeer Region, Lapeer, MI: cut 0.84%Henry Ford Health Warren Hospital, Warren, MI: no cutAscension Genesys Hospital, Grand Blanc, MI: cut 0.10%Mymichigan Medical Center Midland, Midland, MI: cut 0.11%Ascension Providence Rochester Hospital, Rochester, MI: cut 0.44%Huron Valley-Sinai Hospital, Commerce Township, MI: cut 0.30%Henry Ford Health West Bloomfield Hospital, W Bloomfield, MI: cut 0.46%Mymichigan Medical Center Alma, Alma, MI: cut 0.21%Trinity Health Livingston Hospital, Howell, MI: cut 0.20%McLaren Central Michigan, Mount Pleasant, MI: cut 0.05%Mymichigan Medical Center West Branch, West Branch, MI: cut 0.06%Tawas St Joseph Hospital, Tawas City, MI: cut 0.30%Memorial Healthcare, Owosso, MI: cut 0.57%Mymichigan Medical Center Clare, Clare, MI: cut 0.17%McLaren Oakland, Pontiac, MI: cut 0.05%University of Michigan Health-Sparrow Carson, Carson City, MI: no cutSoutheast Michigan Surgical Hospital LLC, Warren, MI: no cutSurgeons Choice Medical Center, Southfield, MI: no cutMymichigan Medical Center Saginaw, Saginaw, MI: cut 0.22%Covenant Medical Center, Saginaw, MI: cut 0.48%

Hospital dots, by cut

  • No cut
  • Under 0.25%
  • 0.25%–0.49%
  • 0.50%–0.99%
  • 1.00%–1.99%
  • 2.00%–3.00%
  • Other hospitals

Dots are sized by Medicare volume and shaded by cut. Select one to open it. Gray dots are other hospitals in the state.

CMS FY2027 Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program Supplemental Data File. Locations geocoded from street addresses (U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder), else ZIP or county centers.

Show table
HospitalCityCutBase payments (dot size)
Covenant Medical CenterSaginaw0.48%$52.5M
Mymichigan Medical Center SaginawSaginaw0.22%$22.3M

Size of the cuts

Figure 2. All 2 hospitals here take a cut, 0.35% on average; across all hospitals 20% take none.
0%10%20%30%40%50% No cut: 0 here (0%); 20% of all hospitals0.0% to 0.1%: 0 here (0%); 18% of all hospitals0.1% to 0.2%: 0 here (0%); 11% of all hospitals0.2% to 0.3%: 1 here (50%); 10% of all hospitals0.3% to 0.4%: 0 here (0%); 8% of all hospitals0.4% to 0.5%: 1 here (50%); 6% of all hospitals0.5% to 0.6%: 0 here (0%); 6% of all hospitals0.6% to 0.7%: 0 here (0%); 4% of all hospitals0.7% to 0.8%: 0 here (0%); 3% of all hospitals0.8% to 0.9%: 0 here (0%); 3% of all hospitals0.9% to 1.0%: 0 here (0%); 2% of all hospitals1.0% to 1.1%: 0 here (0%); 2% of all hospitals1.1% to 1.2%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.2% to 1.3%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.3% to 1.4%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.4% to 1.5%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.5% to 1.6%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.6% to 1.7%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals1.7% to 1.8%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals1.8% to 1.9%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals1.9% to 2.0%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.0% to 2.1%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.1% to 2.2%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.2% to 2.3%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.3% to 2.4%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.4% to 2.5%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.5% to 2.6%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.6% to 2.7%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.7% to 2.8%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.8% to 2.9%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.9% to 3.0%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals 1%2%3%average 0.35%none 0%10%20%30%40%50% No cut: 0 here (0%); 20% of all hospitals0.0% to 0.1%: 0 here (0%); 18% of all hospitals0.1% to 0.2%: 0 here (0%); 11% of all hospitals0.2% to 0.3%: 1 here (50%); 10% of all hospitals0.3% to 0.4%: 0 here (0%); 8% of all hospitals0.4% to 0.5%: 1 here (50%); 6% of all hospitals0.5% to 0.6%: 0 here (0%); 6% of all hospitals0.6% to 0.7%: 0 here (0%); 4% of all hospitals0.7% to 0.8%: 0 here (0%); 3% of all hospitals0.8% to 0.9%: 0 here (0%); 3% of all hospitals0.9% to 1.0%: 0 here (0%); 2% of all hospitals1.0% to 1.1%: 0 here (0%); 2% of all hospitals1.1% to 1.2%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.2% to 1.3%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.3% to 1.4%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.4% to 1.5%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.5% to 1.6%: 0 here (0%); 1% of all hospitals1.6% to 1.7%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals1.7% to 1.8%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals1.8% to 1.9%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals1.9% to 2.0%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.0% to 2.1%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.1% to 2.2%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.2% to 2.3%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.3% to 2.4%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.4% to 2.5%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.5% to 2.6%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.6% to 2.7%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.7% to 2.8%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.8% to 2.9%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals2.9% to 3.0%: 0 here (0%); 0% of all hospitals 0.5%1%1.5%2%2.5%3%average 0.35%none

Bars: Saginaw, MI. Outline: all hospitals. Both as shares, so areas of any size compare. The bar at the left is hospitals with no cut.

CMS FY2027 Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program Supplemental Data File.

Show table
Cut fromtoHospitals hereShare hereShare of all hospitals
No cut—00%20%
0.0%0.1%00%18%
0.1%0.2%00%11%
0.2%0.3%150%10%
0.3%0.4%00%8%
0.4%0.5%150%6%
0.5%0.6%00%6%
0.6%0.7%00%4%
0.7%0.8%00%3%
0.8%0.9%00%3%
0.9%1.0%00%2%
1.0%1.1%00%2%
1.1%1.2%00%1%
1.2%1.3%00%1%
1.3%1.4%00%1%
1.4%1.5%00%1%
1.5%1.6%00%1%
1.6%1.7%00%0%
1.7%1.8%00%0%
1.8%1.9%00%0%
1.9%2.0%00%0%
2.0%2.1%00%0%
2.1%2.2%00%0%
2.2%2.3%00%0%
2.3%2.4%00%0%
2.4%2.5%00%0%
2.5%2.6%00%0%
2.6%2.7%00%0%
2.7%2.8%00%0%
2.8%2.9%00%0%
2.9%3.0%00%0%

Peer groups

Figure 3. The largest group here is group 3, with 1 of the 2 hospitals.
Group 1: no hospital hereGroup 1none0Group 2: no hospital hereGroup 2none0Group 3: 1 hospital, average cut 0.22%Group 3avg cut 0.22%1Group 4: 1 hospital, average cut 0.48%Group 4avg cut 0.48%1Group 5: no hospital hereGroup 5none0 Group 1: no hospital hereGroup 1none0Group 2: no hospital hereGroup 2none0Group 3: 1 hospital, average cut 0.22%Group 3avg cut 0.22%1Group 4: 1 hospital, average cut 0.48%Group 4avg cut 0.48%1Group 5: no hospital hereGroup 5none0

How many hospitals here fall in each dual-eligible peer group. Group 1 serves the fewest low-income patients, group 5 the most. Under each group: its average cut here.

CMS FY2027 Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program Supplemental Data File.

Show table
Peer groupHospitals hereAverage cut
Group 10none
Group 20none
Group 310.22%
Group 410.48%
Group 50none

Which conditions drive the penalties here

Figure 4. Heart attack is the largest part of the estimated dollars here, 40%.
  • All hospitals

Penalized on this condition

Heart attack: 1 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 50%; all hospitals 50%Heart attack1 of 250%COPD: 1 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 50%; all hospitals 50%COPD1 of 250%Heart failure: 1 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 50%; all hospitals 50%Heart failure1 of 250%Pneumonia: 2 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 100%; all hospitals 50%Pneumonia2 of 2100%Bypass surgery: 0 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 0%; all hospitals 49%Bypass (CABG)0 of 20%Hip/knee replacement: 2 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 100%; all hospitals 50%Hip/knee2 of 2100% Heart attack: 1 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 50%; all hospitals 50%Heart attack1 of 2 measured50%COPD: 1 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 50%; all hospitals 50%COPD1 of 2 measured50%Heart failure: 1 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 50%; all hospitals 50%Heart failure1 of 2 measured50%Pneumonia: 2 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 100%; all hospitals 50%Pneumonia2 of 2 measured100%Bypass surgery: 0 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 0%; all hospitals 49%Bypass surgery0 of 2 measured0%Hip/knee replacement: 2 of 2 measured hospitals penalized, 100%; all hospitals 50%Hip/knee replacement2 of 2 measured100%

Share of estimated dollars

Heart attack: $122K of the modeled dollars, 40%Heart attack≈ $122K40%Pneumonia: $88K of the modeled dollars, 29%Pneumonia≈ $88K29%Hip/knee replacement: $45K of the modeled dollars, 15%Hip/knee≈ $45K15%Heart failure: $28K of the modeled dollars, 9%Heart failure≈ $28K9%COPD: $18K of the modeled dollars, 6%COPD≈ $18K6%Bypass surgery: $0 of the modeled dollars, 0%Bypass (CABG)≈ $00% Heart attack: $122K of the modeled dollars, 40%Heart attack≈ $122K40%Pneumonia: $88K of the modeled dollars, 29%Pneumonia≈ $88K29%Hip/knee replacement: $45K of the modeled dollars, 15%Hip/knee replacement≈ $45K15%Heart failure: $28K of the modeled dollars, 9%Heart failure≈ $28K9%COPD: $18K of the modeled dollars, 6%COPD≈ $18K6%Bypass surgery: $0 of the modeled dollars, 0%Bypass surgery≈ $00%

Left: share of measured hospitals penalized on each condition (tick: all hospitals, about half). Right: share of the estimated dollars. Each condition flags about half of the hospitals measured on it by design, because CMS compares a hospital with the median of its peer group, so a bar near the tick is not a finding on its own. Dollars are modeled here: each cut hospital’s estimated dollars split by its conditions’ parts of the cut.

Estimate · CMS FY2027 Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program Supplemental Data File; dollars are modeled here.

Show table
ConditionMeasured herePenalized hereShare penalizedAll hospitals’ shareModeled dollarsShare of dollars
Heart attack2150%50%$122K40%
COPD2150%50%$18K6%
Heart failure2150%50%$28K9%
Pneumonia22100%50%$88K29%
Bypass surgery200%49%$00%
Hip/knee replacement22100%50%$45K15%

Average cut over time

Figure 5. In FY2027, the average cut in Saginaw, MI was 0.35%, against 0.35% across all hospitals in the program.
Shaded: the years whose data reach the claims of January 1, 2020 to June 30, 2020, which CMS left out. 0%0.5%1% 3% cap FY2013: 0.29% here; 0.28% across all hospitals in the programFY2014: 0.36% here; 0.26% across all hospitals in the programFY2015: 0.64% here; 0.50% across all hospitals in the programFY2016: 0.81% here; 0.49% across all hospitals in the programFY2017: 0.69% here; 0.60% across all hospitals in the programFY2018: 0.76% here; 0.61% across all hospitals in the programFY2019: 0.77% here; 0.59% across all hospitals in the programFY2020: 0.98% here; 0.60% across all hospitals in the programFY2021: 0.59% here; 0.58% across all hospitals in the programFY2022: 0.79% here; 0.54% across all hospitals in the programFY2023: 0.23% here; 0.33% across all hospitals in the programFY2024: 0.35% here; 0.34% across all hospitals in the programFY2025: 0.30% here; 0.33% across all hospitals in the programFY2026: 0.36% here; 0.35% across all hospitals in the programFY2027: 0.35% here; 0.35% across all hospitals in the program0.35% ’13’15’17’19’21’23’25’27 Shaded: the years whose data reach the claims of January 1, 2020 to June 30, 2020, which CMS left out. 0%0.5%1% 2%3% cap FY2013: 0.29% here; 0.28% across all hospitals in the programFY2014: 0.36% here; 0.26% across all hospitals in the programFY2015: 0.64% here; 0.50% across all hospitals in the programFY2016: 0.81% here; 0.49% across all hospitals in the programFY2017: 0.69% here; 0.60% across all hospitals in the programFY2018: 0.76% here; 0.61% across all hospitals in the programFY2019: 0.77% here; 0.59% across all hospitals in the programFY2020: 0.98% here; 0.60% across all hospitals in the programFY2021: 0.59% here; 0.58% across all hospitals in the programFY2022: 0.79% here; 0.54% across all hospitals in the programFY2023: 0.23% here; 0.33% across all hospitals in the programFY2024: 0.35% here; 0.34% across all hospitals in the programFY2025: 0.30% here; 0.33% across all hospitals in the programFY2026: 0.36% here; 0.35% across all hospitals in the programFY2027: 0.35% here; 0.35% across all hospitals in the program0.35% The pandemic years’13’14’15’16’17’18’19’20’21’22’23’24’25’26’27

Red: hospitals in Saginaw, MI that are in the FY2027 program. Dashed: every hospital in the FY2027 program, nationwide. Each year averages those in that year’s file. The cap on the cut changed over the years, so a cut in one year is not the same size of penalty in another. Shaded: the years whose data reach the claims of January 1, 2020 to June 30, 2020, which CMS left out.

This site recomputes · CMS Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program supplemental data files, FY2013–FY2027.

Show table
Fiscal yearAverage cut hereAverage cut, all hospitals in the program
FY20130.29%0.28%
FY20140.36%0.26%
FY20150.64%0.50%
FY20160.81%0.49%
FY20170.69%0.60%
FY20180.76%0.61%
FY20190.77%0.59%
FY20200.98%0.60%
FY20210.59%0.58%
FY20220.79%0.54%
FY20230.23%0.33%
FY20240.35%0.34%
FY20250.30%0.33%
FY20260.36%0.35%
FY20270.35%0.35%

Hospitals in Saginaw, MI

Largest cut first. Select a hospital to open its page.

Hospitals in Saginaw, MI, largest cut first
HospitalCutEstimated dollarsPeer groupConditionsBeds
Covenant Medical CenterSaginaw, MI · CCN 2300700.48%$252K4Heart attack: adds to the cut; COPD: adds to the cut; Heart failure: adds to the cut; Pneumonia: adds to the cut; Bypass surgery: measured, adds nothing; Hip/knee replacement: adds to the cutCounted toward the cut: Heart attack, COPD, Heart failure, Pneumonia, and Hip/knee replacement623
Mymichigan Medical Center SaginawSaginaw, MI · CCN 2300770.22%$49K3Heart attack: measured, adds nothing; COPD: measured, adds nothing; Heart failure: measured, adds nothing; Pneumonia: adds to the cut; Bypass surgery: measured, adds nothing; Hip/knee replacement: adds to the cutCounted toward the cut: Pneumonia and Hip/knee replacement268

Download these hospitals as a CSV